Choose the Goulds J5S when you want the most flow in the lower half of the pressure band, an easy back pull-out for service and a pump already wired for 115 V.
Choose the Red Lion RJS-50-PREM when steadier flow near 50 PSI matters, you want three years of warranty cover and your supply is 230 V.
Key specifications
| Specification | Goulds J5S Shallow Well Jet Pump | Red Lion RJS-50-PREM Shallow Well Jet Pump |
|---|---|---|
| Horsepower | 1/2 HP | 1/2 HP |
| Flow at 5 ft lift, 30 PSI | 16.5 GPM | 12.6 GPM |
| Flow at 5 ft lift, 40 PSI | 10.2 GPM | 10 GPM |
| Flow at 5 ft lift, 50 PSI | 5.0 GPM | 6.1 GPM |
| Flow at 15 ft lift, 30 / 40 / 50 PSI | 12.5 / 8.0 / 3.6 GPM | 10 / 7.9 / 4 GPM |
| Flow at 25 ft lift, 30 / 40 / 50 PSI | 8.6 / 6.2 / 1.3 GPM | 6.9 / 6.2 / 2.5 GPM |
| Shut-off pressure at 5 ft lift | 63 PSI | 65 PSI |
| Pressure switch | AS4, preset 30-50 PSI | 30/50 PSI, shuts off at 50 PSI |
| Motor | 115/230 V capacitor start, 3500 RPM; wired for 115 V | 115/230 V with capacitor; factory set for 230 V |
| Amps (115 / 230 V) | 10.8 / 5.4 A maximum load | 11.8 / 5.9 A |
| Suction and discharge | 1-1/4 in NPT suction, 1 in NPT discharge | 1-1/4 in FNPT intake, 1 in FNPT discharge |
| Impeller | Glass-filled composite; diffuser with stainless wear ring | Glass-filled thermoplastic impeller and diffuser |
| Drinking-water listing | NSF/ANSI 61 and 372 | NSF/ANSI 372 (lead free) |
| Warranty | 1 year from installation or 18 months from date code | 3 years from purchase |
Figures: Goulds JS series shallow well jet pumps technical brochure BJS+ R4; Red Lion premium cast iron shallow well jet pump RJS-PREM series product page; Goulds jet pump installation, operation and maintenance manual IM102; Red Lion RJS-PREM series owner's manual 106905101.
Scorecard
| Criterion | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Flow just after cut-in | Goulds J5S Shallow Well Jet Pump | At 30 PSI and a 5 ft lift the Goulds rates 16.5 GPM against 12.6 GPM for the Red Lion. |
| Flow near cut-out | Red Lion RJS-50-PREM Shallow Well Jet Pump | At 50 PSI the Red Lion keeps 6.1 GPM at 5 ft and 2.5 GPM at 25 ft, ahead of the Goulds at both. |
| Ease of service | Goulds J5S Shallow Well Jet Pump | Goulds' back pull-out design lets the motor and impeller come out without disturbing the piping. |
| Warranty length | Red Lion RJS-50-PREM Shallow Well Jet Pump | Red Lion covers the pump for three years from purchase; Goulds covers one year from installation. |
| Middle of the pressure band | Even | At 40 PSI the curves almost match: about 10 GPM at 5 ft and 6.2 GPM at 25 ft for each. |
Where in the pressure band each pump is strong
A shallow well pump never runs at one pressure. It starts at 30 PSI, fills the tank and stops at 50 PSI, and the water you feel at a tap depends on where in that cycle the pump is.
At 30 PSI the Goulds J5S is the stronger pump: 16.5 GPM against 12.6 GPM at a 5 ft lift, and 8.6 GPM against 6.9 GPM at 25 ft. At 40 PSI the two are almost identical. At 50 PSI the order flips, with the Red Lion holding 6.1 GPM at 5 ft where the Goulds drops to 5.0 GPM, and 2.5 GPM at 25 ft where the Goulds falls to 1.3 GPM. In practice the Goulds fills a tank faster from empty, while the Red Lion feeds a running shower more steadily near the top of the cycle.
Which matters more depends on how the house uses water. A family that runs a washing machine, a dishwasher and a shower at once keeps the pump near cut-in for long stretches, where the Goulds has the edge. A small cabin with one tap open at a time spends more of each cycle near the top of the band, where the Red Lion does a little better.
Depth to water
Both pumps are rated for suction lifts down to 25 ft, and both lose capacity as the lift grows. The Goulds goes from 16.5 GPM at 5 ft to 8.6 GPM at 25 ft when measured at 30 PSI. The Red Lion goes from 12.6 GPM to 6.9 GPM at the same pressure. Shut-off pressure, the most either pump can build with the tap closed, is 63 PSI for the Goulds and 65 PSI for the Red Lion at a 5 ft lift.
If your water is deeper than 25 ft below the pump, neither is suitable, however carefully the suction line is sealed, and a convertible jet or submersible is the answer. Our guide to shallow and deep well pumps explains the split, and the shallow well jet pump list shows other options.
Voltage, amps and wiring
Both motors are dual voltage, but they arrive set differently. Goulds wires its 1/2 HP jet pumps for 115 V at the factory, and the voltage change is made inside the motor cover. Red Lion ships the RJS-50-PREM set for 230 V and asks you to turn the voltage selector to 115 V if that is your supply.
Current draw is similar. Goulds' motor table lists a maximum load of 10.8 A at 115 V and 5.4 A at 230 V, with breakers of 25 A and 15 A. Red Lion lists 11.8 A and 5.9 A. Either pump needs a properly fused disconnect, and Red Lion suggests a pressure switch with a low-pressure cut-off to protect a pump that loses prime.
Build and serviceability
Goulds has built its J-series around service. The back pull-out design lets the motor, impeller and diffuser come out without breaking the pipe joints, a nozzle clean-out plug in the case helps clear a blocked jet, and a diaphragm keeps water in the casing so the seal never runs dry. The diffuser has a stainless wear ring for sandy water, and the pump is listed to NSF/ANSI 61 and 372 for drinking water.
Red Lion uses a cast iron casing with a glass-filled thermoplastic impeller and diffuser, and lists NSF/ANSI 372 lead-free compliance and CSA certification for electrical safety. Repair parts are listed in its owner's manual, but it does not describe a pull-out design. Its manual walks through priming with either an in-line check valve or a foot valve, and warns that the pump must never run dry before it is primed.
Tank, relief valve and warranty
Set-up is similar. Red Lion asks for a tank pre-charge of 28 PSI, a pressure relief valve rated to handle the pump's flow at 75 PSI, and never a check valve between the pump and the tank. Goulds asks for the pre-charge to sit 2 PSI below cut-in, which also gives 28 PSI on a 30/50 switch. See our guide to pressure tank sizing for drawdown.
The warranties are far apart. Red Lion covers the RJS-50-PREM for three years from the consumer's purchase date. Goulds covers the J5S for one year from installation or 18 months from the date code, whichever comes first. For a pump that runs every time a tap opens, those extra two years are worth weighing.
Who each one fits
The Goulds J5S Shallow Well Jet Pump fits if
- Your household draws heavily right after the pump starts.
- Your supply is 115 V and you want no rewiring.
- Easy service without breaking pipe joints matters.
- The well water carries a little sand.
The Red Lion RJS-50-PREM Shallow Well Jet Pump fits if
- You want steadier flow near the top of the cycle.
- A 230 V circuit already feeds the pump.
- You want three years of warranty cover.
- The pump will sit where a replacement is hard to arrange.
Questions readers ask
Is Goulds or Red Lion better for a shallow well?
Neither wins outright on these 1/2 HP models. The Goulds J5S moves more water at low pressure and is easier to service. The Red Lion RJS-50-PREM holds more flow near 50 PSI and has a three-year warranty against the Goulds one-year cover.
Can either pump lift water from more than 25 ft?
No. Both are shallow well jet pumps rated for suction lifts of 25 ft or less. Beyond that the flow tables end and the pump struggles to hold prime. Use a convertible jet with an ejector in the well, or a submersible, for deeper water.
Do I need to rewire either pump?
Check the motor setting first. Goulds ships its 1/2 HP jet pumps wired for 115 V, while Red Lion sets the RJS-50-PREM for 230 V at the factory. Both can be changed to the other voltage, and the setting must match your supply before power is applied.
Can I swap a Goulds J5S for a Red Lion RJS-50-PREM?
Usually yes. Both use a 1-1/4 in suction and a 1 in discharge and ship with a 30/50 switch, so the piping and tank settings carry over. Confirm the voltage and the mounting position, and prime the new pump fully before starting it.
Final verdict
These pumps are closer than the brand debate suggests. At 40 PSI their curves almost overlap. The Goulds J5S pulls ahead at the start of each cycle and is the easier pump to service, while the Red Lion RJS-50-PREM holds more water near cut-out and offers three years of cover. If warranty and steady pressure matter most, lean Red Lion; if fast fill and serviceability matter, lean Goulds.

